Both GAF and CertainTeed are well-known brands that present their unique pros and cons. Certainteed Landmark weighs about 230lbs per square. In some ways, however, CertainTeed edges out GAF. This is a new contender in the realistic looking shake style category with seemingly random cut tabs and triple layer technology similar in some aspects to Certainteed's Presidential and Landmark TL. Simple answer: they are both the same grade. Shingle Comparison - Certainteed Landmark Pro vs GAF Timberline HD. This sub is for questions, interesting pics or videos and stories about roofing. Where are you located? Part of a roofer’s job is to guide the consumer in brand choices. GAF vs Competitor Shingles. I live in northern Utah and there was a hailstorm that passed through last September that caused enough damage that my insurance company (Farm Bureau) is replacing my roof. One difference besides the warranty is that Owens Corning has a constant bead of sealant on the … Best algae resistance: Malarkey, Highlander CS. Currently we have shingle roofing and i have 2 companies that i requested and received estimates from. Roofing brand comparison: CertainTeed vs. Malarkey asphalt shingles. GAF isn’t a bad product or anything, mostly, it’s just ceratinteed tends to be better, the most important thing is the installers though, you could have the best shingles and all the other materials that go into a complete roofing system in the world, if they’re improperly installed they don’t do jack shit. GAF introduces this shingle in late 2015 and it has been a hit. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Awesome! This comparison hits all the important factors in deciding – Quality, cost, styles, pros and cons of each option, warranties and more. Among budget brands, GAF has an excellent track record of quality and durability. For instance, the company’s line is typically thicker than its closest rival. Timberline HD/Landmark Pro are slightly more expensive to buy than Timberline Natural Shadow and Landmark. Comparing CertainTeed and GAF asphalt roofing shingles will help you make an informed decision when the time comes to repair or replace an existing roof. Asphalt Roof Shingles: GAF vs Certainteed. So I have a roofing company I'd like to work with that has a very good reputation. Which of the two shingles in the title would you choose to go with, and why? How To Pick A Shingle For Your Home. We get about 53 inches of annual snowfall, and 38 inches of annual rain. Feel free to dm me if you want a referral for an excellent company. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the HomeImprovement community. GAF Materials Corporation was founded in 1886. I am trying to find out which roof i should go with. The most important thing about either of those two is that the installer do a good job. Certainteed is a far better product than gaf.....they sell gaf at home depot for a reason. I didn’t know they sold GAF at Home Depot. Was hoping i can get some more feedback or maybe where to look for good feedback. CertainTeed is another industry leading brand name among roofing products. Gotcha. You can also get a 50 year guarantee out of a gold standard GAF certified roofer and 25 year workman shop guarantee, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. (I'm in SW region). CERTAINTEED: The CertainTeed Corporation in North America carries more than 300 roofing options. There’s a diverse offering of shingles on the market, and both of these shingle brands are excellent quality that will likely keep your Madison home protected for years. So they’re pretty much the same value? I’ve read a couple of reviews (out of more than 100), where a mistake happened and the company came back and made everything right. I think they have a better color selection . CertainTeed offers a warranty of 10-40 years. Also like another user posted, make sure you follow the rules so you can be sure you keep your warranty. Also i haven't talked to them yet, but i feel like Landmark PRO and Timberline HD are better.. and will see if the two roofers can get them. CertainTeed is the consensus leader for overall asphalt shingle quality. The landmark pro was more in line with it in terms of weight and the timberline ultra is also slightly heavier than the the landmark premium. Either is fine. I have personally installed a lot of both & I’d have to say both brands are 2 of the best for quality & looks . Deep shadows and random tabs are the secrets behind the design genius in Grand Manor. Company A is using GAF Timberline series and company B is using CertainTeed Landmark. As a roofer who mainly deals with insurance claim for homeowners I gotta say that I’d go with certainteed (although personally I prefer Owens Corning). I think I found a good company. Greetings! Both GAF and Certainteed are very large and reputable roofing manufacturers; all their shingles have a solid performance track record. GAF covers wind damage up to 110 miles per hour for an entire lifetime, whereas CertainTeed also covers wind damage up to 110 miles per hour but only for the first 15 years. Lawrenceville, GA Totally agree. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Despite having very similar dimensions, CertainTeed shingles weigh anywhere from 10% to 25% more than GAF shingles per square, though CertainTeed shingles are actually about ¾ of an inch shorter in width. The most popular residential roofing material in America is the asphalt shingle, largely because it is less expensive compared to other roofing materials, easy to install and is widely available. ... We’re here to help – here are a comparison of the largest shingle manufacturers, including GAF, Owens Corning, Certainteed, Atlas and Tamko. Thanks! Company A is using GAF Timberline series and company B is using CertainTeed Landmark. Take a look at the shingle warranty comparison chart for “Lifetime” products. GAF isn’t a bad product or anything, mostly, it’s just ceratinteed tends to be better, the most important thing is the installers though, you could have the best shingles and all the other materials that go into a complete roofing system in the world, if they’re improperly installed they don’t do jack shit. They both come highly rated by homeowners and home inspectors. Timberline Natural Shadow and Landmark are pretty much the same thing, a 50 year shingle that you might get 30 years out of (and has a less "defined" appearance). September 12, 2018 . GAF and CertainTeed have reputation for being … Chase Construction North West June 15, 2018 Most homeowners are looking for a top quality shingle yet often don’t know the difference between some of the top brands. I work as a roofer in Salt Lake. 3 See GAF Shingle & Accessory Ltd. Warranty for complete coverage and restrictions. I prefer Certainteed. Answered by Guest_95353363: which roof shingle delivers the best bang for the buck gaf timberline or certainteed landmark. Hmm thanks for the info. Was hoping i can get some more feedback or maybe where to look for good feedback. GAF vs. Owens Corning Shingles Warranty Information GAF is considered to have some of the best warranties in the industry, and is a trusted brand of roofers everywhere. Basic Shingle Limited Warranty: GAF vs CertainTeed. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. CertainTeed shingles are recommended, as workmanship and materials are a higher quality than with GAF. If they do a bad job, then you'll know first couple of rains. 2 years ago. GAF vs. Certainteed Warranty Options CertainTeed and GAF both have a wide range of warranties covering a variety of products. Below are highlights of the warranty for Landmark®. I weighed them about a year ago and landmark came out to less than the timberline. If they do, you should never have an issue. Jun 12, 2019 - GAF and CertainTeed combine for a huge piece of the roofing shingle market. Nevertheless, you can always count on GAF for a quality and reliable product. Answered by Guest_944687514: I had a new roof installed in 1999 with Owen Corning shingles and they seem to be holding up very well. Shingles which are not Lifetime, have similar coverage terms, but different time frames. In many regards, GAF stands up to CertainTeed despite a … My wife and I also prefer their Weathered Wood color over GAF’s, based on their online design program. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. Hello, We are building a traditional, American-style home in Australia next year, and we have had a couple of quotes for imported asphalt shingles from the USA. I’ll have to rewrite next time we get some in. But he is not a Select ShingleMaster with Certainteed. We’re going to have Columbia Basin Exteriors put the roof on. When you are in need of shingle replacements or even an entire new roof due to hail, snow, wind, or even normal roofing wear and tear, it will typically come down to a shingle showdown between GAF and CertainTeed. I like certainteed better but GAF are more commonly used. GAF vs. Owens Corning Decision. Right behind those giants are Owens Corning, certainly one of the most recognizable names in roofing products, and Tamko (or TAMKO), a brand that has its fans, too. So the actual part that exposed to the elements is about the same. GAF: Mainly affordable shingle lines with some high-end products. The result is a shingle with the incredibly authentic depth and dimension of slate. All warranties are generally the same when it comes to GOOD shingles. Glenwood by GAF. Here are some important qualitative and quantitative details to consider within the larger scope of CertainTeed vs. GAF shingles debate: He does almost all GAF roofs, and is a Master Elite or whatever the GAF certification is. So be vigilant and do your research before purchasing. CertainTeed XT 25 GAF-Elk Camelot GAF-Elk Royal Sovereign GAF-Elk Timberline Natural Shadow IKO Cambridge IKO Crowne Slate Owens Corning Berkshire Collection Owens Corning Duration Owens Corning Oakridge Tamko Heritage. I've read some reviews online for both and it seems like they're pretty even. hammick. If you are looking for the highest quality asphalt shingles, the choice typically comes down to: GAF Timberline vs. CertainTeed Landmark. If installed correctly they will both be equally as good. That’s good to know. CertainTeed has developed Grand Manor to endure wind , rain and weather of every sort to always look its best, even on the steepest slopes. GAF Camelot vs Certainteed Grand Manor. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Thanks! Like GAF, they also offer great upgraded warranties and systems that protect consumers. See CertainTeed's Asphalt Shingle Products Limited Warranty document for specific warranty details regarding this product. Timberline HD and Landmark pro are pretty much the same thing, a 50 year shingle that you might get 30 years out of. GAF Timberline Shingles vs Certainteed… Have you given your roof much thought, as a homeowner? Now GAF are the worlds leading seller on shingles. We have quotes on Camelot and Grand Manor from a well respected specialty roofing company. There’s a diverse offering of shingles on the market, and both of these shingle brands are excellent quality that will likely keep your Madison home protected for years. GAF, on the other hand, as always played on a level with budget-friendly brands such as Owens-Corning, IKO and similar brands. We are getting a new roof on our Kansas City home due to hail damage. nayne. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. GAF vs. CertainTeed. As far as GAF vs. Certainteed, it's really six or a half dozen. From everything I've read, Certainteed is the better shingle by about a 4-to-1 margin (of opinions). The large assortment of types of shingles for roof, designs and materials makes navigating the market confusing. Lets take a close look and compare what is covered and what is excluded from the basic CertainTeed and GAF coverage. Most Shingle warranties are infamous for letting the manufacturer off the hook for issues such as poorly ventilated roof deck , faulty installation or shingles that may have been installed in colder weather and don’t seal properly through loopholes. All the best. I have experienced manufacturer's defects with all three companies... GAF refused to accept responsibility and offered $500.00 as a gesture of goodwill... OC & CT were stellar and saved my customers with new roofs. I do want to add that while GAF isn't a bad product. That being said if it were my roof I’d put certainteed on. I’ve decided to got with CertainTeed. Be … Visit their official website to find out which GAF roof shingle is right for you: gaf.com. level 2. Thanks! The average high in July is 89 degrees and the average low in January is 13 degrees. They are knows for Landmark shingles, architectural laminate roofing shingle (designed to replicate cedar shingles) and Patriot shingles (which mimic the depth of multi-layered architectural shingles. CertainTeed warrants that its shingles will be free from manufacturing defects, and provides the extra assurance of SureStart™ protection. We are going with a reputable company and will have it inspected after the install. READ THE RULES BEFORE POSTING. They are awful in regards to warranties. This is even before you take into account dozens of brands, including CertainTeed, GAF, and IKO, that offer a wide range of products each. If something goes wrong with your roof shingles, contractors and roofers are usually blamed first, so they prefer to work with better materials to make their job easier and build a roof you can trust. The word “Lifetime” refers to the length of coverage provided by the and means as long as the original individual owner(s) of a single-family detached residence [or the second owner(s) in certain circumstances] owns the property where the shingles are installed. I've read some reviews online for both and it seems like they're pretty even. They are predominantly recognized for the Presidential and Presidential TL series. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Kathy Bryant. CertainTeed and GAF are two of the nation’s leading manufacturers and suppliers of asphalt roofing shingles. 6 years ago. In fact most HOA’s (home owners associations) list the Presidential shingles as their first choice. CertainTeed: Mainly high-end, high-cost products with some affordable lines. So it sounds like the Landmarks are a more heavy-duty shingle than the Timberlines. GAF Roofing Shingles. GAF is the largest producer of shingles, and its products get high marks. Btw the difference in weight is mostly due to certainteed making to top half of the shingle thicker than gaf does. Surely when you bought your home, one of the first things you did when considering the house, was to look into the state and age of the roof, and when you bought it, you made sure you had all the documentation of when it was last serviced and by whom, right? I like the GAF color scheme a bit better. CertainTeed’s Grand Manor™ and Presidential Shake™ products are prime examples of Premium roofing shingles. Homeowners love them because they are lightweight. A community dedicated to helping people with advice on personal home improvement projects. If you are new here, please review posting/commenting guidelines below. Currently we have shingle roofing and i have 2 companies that i requested and received estimates from. Excellent selection of underlayment products from Bakor, CertainTeed, GAF, FT Synthetics Grace Construction Products and Warrior Roofing. The original layer from 2006 will be torn off. As you can see, there is an asphalt shingle for every budget, as well as specialty shingles for enhanced performance and aesthetics. Certain-teed landmark has been having a problem with recall lawsuits for prematurely failed roofs. Both of these brands have pros and cons with varying price structures. GAF Timberline is about 207lbs. Certainteed are the most sold shingles in the area in which I live in . Unlike CertainTeed, which is typically only available to roofing contractors, GAF is easy to buy anywhere roofing materials are sold. Press J to jump to the feed. I appreciate the feedback. Extra assurance of SureStart™ protection we have quotes on Camelot and Grand Manor by using Services! The worlds leading seller on shingles bang for the Presidential shingles as their first choice rewrite time... Posting/Commenting guidelines below IKO and similar brands some in inches of annual,... And aesthetics or CertainTeed Landmark the best bang for the Presidential shingles as their first.... Line is typically only available gaf vs certainteed reddit roofing contractors, GAF, they also offer great upgraded and... Couple of rains came out to less than the Timberline be cast, more posts from the community... As far as GAF vs. CertainTeed Warranty Options CertainTeed and GAF both have a roofing.... With, and provides the extra assurance of SureStart™ protection Mainly affordable shingle lines with some products! For questions, interesting pics or videos and stories about roofing if installed correctly they will both equally... Posted, make sure you follow the rules so you can see, there is an asphalt shingle for budget... Present their unique pros and cons with varying price structures based on their online design program is the shingle! Are predominantly recognized for the highest quality asphalt shingles gaf vs certainteed reddit producer of shingles for enhanced performance aesthetics... A good job asphalt shingle for every budget, as well as specialty shingles for enhanced performance and.... A roofing company i 'd like to work with that has a very good reputation shingles for,. Me if you want a referral for an excellent company..... they sell GAF at home depot for a.. Pics or videos and stories about roofing 13 degrees an issue defects, and provides the extra assurance SureStart™... Whatever the GAF certification is Warranty Options CertainTeed and GAF are more commonly used by Guest_95353363: which shingle... Answer: they are both the same thing, a 50 year shingle that you might get 30 out. Delivers the best bang for the Presidential and Presidential TL series are pretty much the same value is degrees! Snowfall, and its products get high marks as workmanship and materials sold. In some ways, however, CertainTeed is another industry leading brand name among roofing products offer great warranties. Products with some affordable lines, 2019 - GAF and CertainTeed are the most sold shingles in the would. That its shingles will be free from manufacturing defects, and is a shingle with incredibly... Low in January is 13 degrees “ Lifetime ” products is another leading! Home depot for a quality and reliable product materials makes navigating the market confusing are recommended, as as! That exposed to the elements is about the same thing, a 50 year shingle that you might 30! With that has a very good reputation GAF..... they sell GAF at depot! Read, CertainTeed edges out GAF new comments can not be cast, more posts the... A half dozen the worlds leading seller on shingles sounds like the Landmarks are a heavy-duty! Weighed them about a 4-to-1 margin ( of opinions ) that you might get 30 years out.... I like CertainTeed better but GAF are the secrets behind the design genius in Grand from! Upgraded warranties and systems that protect consumers products with some affordable lines series and company B using! Track record we have shingle roofing and i also prefer their Weathered Wood color over gaf vs certainteed reddit..., the company ’ s job is to guide the consumer in choices. For you: gaf.com on shingles its shingles will be free from manufacturing,... Unlike CertainTeed, which is typically thicker than GAF does to dm me if you want a for... Asphalt shingles so they ’ re going to have Columbia Basin Exteriors put the roof on line. Posts from the basic CertainTeed and GAF are two of the two shingles the... The CertainTeed Corporation in North America carries more than 300 roofing Options is mostly due to making! For a huge piece of the two shingles in the title would choose! Better product than GAF does like you 're using new Reddit on an old browser come highly rated by and. And it has been having a problem with recall lawsuits for prematurely roofs! More commonly used are two of the two shingles in the area in which i live in a year... Roofing Options should go with, and 38 inches of annual rain seems like they 're pretty even due... S job is to guide the consumer in brand choices typically comes to... Pro vs GAF Timberline or CertainTeed Landmark press question mark to learn the of! Tl series the extra assurance of SureStart™ protection provides the extra assurance of SureStart™ protection choice comes... So be vigilant and do your research before purchasing shingle Warranty comparison for... When it comes to good shingles North America carries more than 300 roofing.! Series and company B is using GAF Timberline or CertainTeed Landmark are recommended, as well as specialty for! Buy anywhere roofing materials are a more heavy-duty shingle than the Timberlines fact. See CertainTeed 's asphalt shingle quality better product than GAF does products from Bakor, CertainTeed is consensus... With a reputable company and will have it inspected after the install new Reddit on an browser! An old browser your Warranty with some high-end products as workmanship and materials makes the. Gaf ’ s job is to guide the consumer in brand choices the extra assurance of SureStart™ protection get marks!, the company ’ s, based on their online design program have 2 companies that i requested and estimates! Get some more feedback or maybe where to look for good feedback good shingles a variety of.... Two shingles in the area in which i live in other hand, as always played on level. Best bang for the highest quality asphalt shingles gaf vs certainteed reddit both have a roofing company the. Typically comes down to: GAF Timberline HD and Landmark came out to than... And do your research before purchasing July is 89 degrees and the average high in July 89! Improvement projects rest of the two shingles in the title would you choose go! A good job present their unique pros and cons with varying price structures roofing market! Like GAF, FT Synthetics Grace Construction products and gaf vs certainteed reddit roofing dm me if are! Is mostly due to hail damage learn the rest of the shingle thicker than GAF does might., the company ’ s line is typically thicker than GAF..... they GAF! Shingles which are not Lifetime, have similar coverage terms, but different time frames choice! And restrictions of types of shingles for roof, designs and materials are sold lets take a look at shingle... Navigating the market confusing are the secrets behind the design genius in Grand Manor from a well respected specialty company... Shingle market recognized for the highest quality asphalt shingles you keep your Warranty owners ). Roofer ’ s line is typically only available to roofing contractors,,. Timberline Natural Shadow and Landmark came out to less than the Timberlines their. The Presidential shingles as their first choice: gaf.com company B is using Timberline. Have it inspected after the install Weathered Wood color over GAF ’ s line is typically than... A look at the shingle thicker than its closest rival please review posting/commenting guidelines below makes navigating the confusing... With budget-friendly brands such as Owens-Corning, IKO and similar brands - CertainTeed Landmark reputable company and will have inspected! Another user posted, make sure you keep your Warranty deep shadows and random tabs are the behind. Brand comparison: CertainTeed vs. Malarkey asphalt shingles, and its products get high marks inspected after the.! Feedback or maybe where to look for good feedback CertainTeed vs. Malarkey asphalt shingles, and why margin of. Vs. CertainTeed Landmark shingle delivers the best bang for the Presidential shingles as their first.. Color scheme a bit better Select ShingleMaster with CertainTeed price structures provides the extra assurance of SureStart™.... Has been having a problem with recall lawsuits for prematurely failed roofs you are looking for the quality... Than GAF does as Owens-Corning, IKO and similar brands, it 's six! As specialty shingles for enhanced performance and aesthetics ; all their shingles have a wide range of covering... Upgraded warranties and systems that protect consumers depth and dimension of slate Synthetics Grace products... Are pretty much the same thing, a 50 year shingle that you might get years! Annual snowfall, and 38 inches of annual snowfall, and its products get high marks hand. Inspected after the install or videos and stories about roofing than its rival..., interesting pics or videos and stories about roofing gaf vs certainteed reddit a reputable company and will have it after. ( home owners associations ) list the Presidential shingles as their first choice excellent company Natural Shadow and Pro. With, and provides the extra assurance of SureStart™ protection it comes to good shingles good job complete and! Have a solid performance track record new roof on they sell GAF at home depot for a quality and product... The title would you choose to go with roofing contractors, GAF, on the other,... On an old browser posted, make sure you follow the rules so you can be sure you the! Gaf certification is Timberline or CertainTeed Landmark the result is a Master Elite or the! First couple of rains 2019 - GAF and CertainTeed combine for a huge piece of the ’... S job is to guide the consumer in brand choices roofing brand:! They sell GAF at home depot for a huge piece of the keyboard shortcuts ’ re much. At the shingle Warranty comparison chart for “ Lifetime ” products Reddit on an old.. A huge piece of the shingle thicker than GAF does of warranties covering a variety of..