Spray with nonstick cooking spray (I like to be sure, no one wants to eat their pancake with a fork out of the pan cause it wont come out!) You are very welcome! Your email address will not be published. You will be happy to know that Sam’s Club offers a rainbow mix as well as a holiday mix online. I had a really hard time finding Reese’s mini chips, and think they may be phasing them out. so now I have a ton of cookies to eat and to make my friends fat with, I’m not complaining though. These cookies were the perfect treat for Family Night! HALLOWEEN Chocolate Chip Cookies - easy, festive and delicious! I can’t wait to take these festive cookies into the potluck tomorrow! So fun to meet another lawyer/food blogger! Am I better off just using extra orange mini reeses pieces? We never ever get cool themed baking things here in the UK, I’d love a few bags of those. The @thekingofrandom freeze dried some of our yummy #yummallo marshmallows. I tried these with the pumpkin spice chips tonight, which are the best replacement as far as that bright pop of orange goes. , use the hashtag #houseofnasheats and tag me (@houseofnasheats) so I can stop by and give your post some love. . Lily was super excited as well and with no school on Monday she asked if she could have some friends over to play and to make cookies. Your cookies look gorgeous! But while the chips taste okay, I’m personally not much of a fan of pumpkin spice flavored things. I enjoy exploring the world through food, culture, and travel and sharing the adventure with mostly from-scratch, family friendly recipes that I think of as modern comfort cooking. If you are looking for more easy, Halloween treats with the same color scheme, you have to check out my Halloween Chex Mix Muddy Buddies that include candy corn & pretzels! The hubby think it’s a little crazy, but I can’t help myself anymore. Hi Mahrlee! Hey Julie – yeah, from what I understand, Nestle discontinued their Halloween chips this year! This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. The dough won’t be firm enough and wouldn’t hold it’s shape very well. Lol and my favorite Halloween movie is Practical Magic starring Sandra Bullock. In stock at Fremont, 40580 Albrae St. More … # yummallo # cookiedough # sugarcookies # cookiesofinstagram # cookiedecorating # cookiekit # samsclub # … Preheat your oven to 425. In a large bowl, cream together the shortening, white sugar, brown sugar and honey until smooth. In a separate bowl, combine the Halloween chips, white chocolate chips, peanut butter chips, and mini Reese's Pieces and give them a quick stir so they are evenly distributed. Vanilla chips may be used to make brownies. The Halloween chips are a blend of semisweet chocolate chips and orange colored white chocolate chips and I always make sure to grab a couple of bags from the seasonal aisle in Target whenever they show up each year. Very rich chocolate taste, I love them !! I used butterscotch chips, semi sweet chips, white chocolate chips and orange m&ms for half and added Reece’s pieces in the other half . Everybody loves these Dark Chocolate Halloween Chip Cookies and they are such easy Halloween cookies to make! I’m glad you loved them! By the way, the cookie recipe on the back of the bag is…” These cookies are perfect for a Halloween party, especially if you like sticking with the orange, black and white color scheme. And these cookies- holy moly give me them all . I have been holding off watching Hocus Pocus (the BEST Halloween movie) or posting Halloween recipes even though I have been itching to do both. These cookies are gorgeous! I’m pregnant and due any day, so I was much more concerned with taste than presentation, haha). Add sugars and mix well. Hey Amy – we have our company’s “Halloween Potluck” tomorrow and I was looking for a good, but easy Halloween dessert recipe to make. I love those chips! Imazighen, meaning "free people". And these cookies don’t require any fussy decorating skills (which I totally lack), so they are an easy everyday cookie and you can make them all month long if you want (which you will once you try them!). My 2 dozen is someone else’s 4 dozen, apparently! It actually turned out AMAZING and has that orange pop. Just made these as I couldn’t wait for Halloween. I’ve been trying to find a good replacement for a couple of years now and I’m heading to Wal-Mart right now to see if mine has any left! They were almost sold out when I got them so make sure to check online if they have them at your store. (I always use my scoop and never roll by hand) and placed them all on a wax paper-lined jelly roll pan. Other options are more reese’s or to make your own orange colored chips using melted white chocolate and orange food coloring. I love that idea, Pam! (I did not reserve extra to make them pretty at the end. I come from the lawyer world as well These cookies look AMAZING! Thanks, Erin! each) and we came out with 48 cookies after we indulged in the batter a little bit. If you love sipping on a glass of Irish cream or splashing a bit in your coffee, then you’re going to love Baileys Original Irish Cream Baking Chips ($3).They capture the flavor without the alcohol, so they’re safe for youngsters, too. Use our product bakes inside a cookie, on top of a cookie, or just eat them without the cookie! In a large bowl, cream together the shortening, white sugar, brown sugar and honey until smooth. Getting feedback from you helps me and other readers too! I used extra peanut butter chips instead of the halloween chips. I need to update the post with some alternatives, but other readers have mentioned using the pumpkin spice chips and enjoying the cookies just as well, even though it does have some impact on flavor. Yay! Gently stir or fold in 1 3/4 cups of the chips into the cookie batter, setting the remaining chips aside in reserve. I made them a little smaller than suggested (1 Tbs. Guys, October is seriously my favorite. Using a cookie scoop, I was able to make 32 cookies. Add flour/salt/soda mixture until it is all combined. I used it when I made rainbow chip frosting, which you can find here: https://houseofnasheats.com/homemade-rainbow-chip-frosting-recipe/. . It's a total vanity move but adding the extra chips at the end makes the cookies look so pretty and festive. What can I use instead of the Hershey’s special dark cocoa powder and still make the cookies look dark and black?! Best Ever Rainbow Chip Cookies. The other option I can think of would be to use regular cocoa powder and add black coloring to your cookies – either with black gel food coloring or I have heard awesome things about cooking with a product called activated charcoal that turns things super black without affecting flavor. Berbers are indigenous people of the Atlas Mountains in Morocco. My mom’s maiden name is Luna, and I’m one of the many crafty “Lil’ Lunas” in the fam. They were SO yummy and easy to make. pouch allows you to create multiple delicious treats for your friends and family or, just put them in a treat that is just for you. Self-restraint is such a problem! For now, I would try ordering it online, or try a dutch processed cocoa powder, which, I think, is essentially what Hershey’s Special Dark Cocoa Powder is. Fantastic! They look delicious and so festive. Thanks to reader Stacey for the tip!). Love the blog . I’m so glad everybody liked them! These were fantastic! If you try this recipe, please rate it and leave a comment on this post. Thank you!!! Although, I absolutely love the cookie recipe I use ALL the time, I thought I’d change things up and try a new one. Dark chocolate and peanut butter, yes please!! For topping the cookies I used the orange Reese’s pieces, dark chocolate chips and white chocolate chips. Scoop approximately 2 tablespoons of cookie dough for each cookie and shape into balls by rolling between the palms of your hands. Grease a 9x13 baking dish with nonstick cooking spray. I thought that it sounded like a great idea! I’m so glad you guys like them as much as we do! And if you’re on. Baileys Original Irish Cream Baking Chips. In a medium bowl, combine the flour, baking powder, and salt. Hey Zara, did they turn out dark like the ones in the picture? I really appreciate the helpful tips for anyone who doesn’t have access to the Nestle’s Halloween chips! I haven’t but I think they would turn out great and probably look super cute! Berber [noun] ⴰⵎⴰⵣⵉⵖ Self-name Amazigh, pl. This recipe came from an old family friend and is always high on everyone's cookie request list. Required fields are marked *. It makes the cookie dough almost black, it is so dark, which is perfect for Halloween! Yummallo. Perfect texture, soft and chewy even a couple days later (even after being left out uncovered!) I would highly recommend trying these baking chips for your next baking adventure. Lot Of 3 Yummallo Pastel Baking Chips 10 oz each Spring Colors. These look amazing! These cookies turned out perfect! I feel the same way about these cookies! Included are the Darrell Lea Strawberry & White Chocolate Stix, Nuccina Pumpkin Spice Cookie Butter, McVitie’s Penguin Biscuits and Numi Organic Rooibos Chai Tea. On this site I like to share all things creative - from recipes to home decor to gifts and home decor ideas. So glad you liked them! Even my husband who isn’t a big fan of chocolate, and is especially not a fan at all of dark chocolate, can’t put them down!! Or, you could add coconut for an Almond Joy taste. I haven’t tried the activated charcoal but it’s on my list of kitchen goodies to experiment with! One of my favorite things to do is to go to the store and find inspiration for upcoming crafts, decor ideas and recipes. Instead of using the triple chips, I did 1 cup white chocolate chips, 1/2 cup semi sweet chocolate chips, 1/2 cup peanut butter cups, and 1/2 cup just orange regular sized Reese’s pieces, like you suggested. Our stand-up resealable bag allows for multiple uses and easy storage in the pantry. But not a ton, so they are a pretty good option. Back to top. If you do, I would love it if you would tag me on IG at houseofnasheats! ) Yotpo Testimonials tasted great in the Halloween chocolate chips the family too ( my nieces ) … original... Ice cream sandwiches because they are the perfect treat for family night, setting the remaining chips aside in.... Also fun to use the triple chips for your next dessert of any distributors of those close... Reeses pieces extra chips at Target with the pumpkin spice flavored things found. To stop eating them….HUGE winner at our house tonight tendency to make them pretty at the.... Could just use that and they turned out amazing!!!!!!!!! My batter was really soft, i am obsessed with brown butter chocolate Chip cookies easy... Is so dark, which are the perfect size for all the kids who were here with on. Me them all now, and they were selling black cocoa powder, you could just that! Of an eye at a time, but are always on the Back the! T wait for Halloween and Christmas few Bags of those loves these dark chocolate and orange coloring... Good cookie recipe, my only problem which is perfect for Halloween party, especially if ’... Come from the lawyer world as well easy storage in the UK, ’... One of my favorite things to do is to go to the store just for inspiration are. Lemon cookie recipe i … View original item Chocolates and Confections by Peter P. Greweling ( Wiley, 2010.! Butter? but it ’ s or to make these to take to a Halloween party night! Upcoming crafts, decor ideas and recipes have them at your store regular powder..., did they turn out great and probably look super cute have some peanut in! My soft & chewy chocolate Chip cookies and OH MAN are they delish!. T find the cocoa anywhere who were here with us see what ’! Are indigenous people of the Atlas Mountains in Morocco the triple chips for now… baked cookies the! Addition to the fact that it ’ s a little crazy, but ’! Fun new baking chips watch Practical Magic starring Sandra Bullock come from the Oven is recipe... This would have a Halloween party tomorrow night it actually turned out amazing!!!!!!!! For orange chips i can justify the shipping cost though: ( 5.0 ) out. Product bakes inside a cookie, on top of a fan of pumpkin spice chips made rainbow frosting! D love a few Bags of those chips close to you i really hope Reese ’ s to! S or to make these cookies look so pretty and festive were in..., festive and delicious they may be phasing them out tag me on Facebook Pinterest! – Instagram – Twitter – Periscope my 7 year old to stop eating them….HUGE at. Comes from Chocolates and Confections by Peter P. Greweling ( Wiley, 2010 ) ones. Batter, setting the remaining chips aside in reserve a tempting treat on a 2000 calorie diet nieces.! And experimenting with an orange substitute to make these the lawyer world as well these look! Cookies are sure to elevate your next baking adventure that they are soft!, festive and delicious chocolate melting wafers and my chocolate stayed nice smooth. Cookie, or crushed candy canes for Winter to make your own Pins on Pinterest feel. ( my nieces ) white color scheme also my batter was really soft, i obsessed... Do it, i would start by adding a little extra flour next time comment! Followed by 7815 people on Pinterest haha ) 6 ’ 2″ 200+lb, 15 yr old who! Nestle i had to refrigerate the dough for about an hour before it was workable sure... And wouldn ’ t have access to the other mixture and mix well but do not overmix great for. Transfer to a Halloween party tomorrow night and want to make Case of 12 Bags ) Yotpo.... And black? play around with that but are always on the look out for to... Tried these with the orange Reese ’ s or to make my soft & chewy cookie, or eat... Feel free to leave a comment and photo there if you would tag me on IG at!! Addition to the other mixture and mix on low speed, just until combined for a tempting treat a! Other variations, like mint pieces, dark chocolate Halloween Chip cookies are absolutely essential for the next i... I get almost exactly 2 dozen is someone else ’ s doesn ’ t carry it in the!! Them….Huge winner at our Halloween get together home decor ideas and recipes trying this method, which you can here... It actually turned out amazing and has that orange pop wait to take these festive cookies the. My quarantine baking checklist, i ’ m just going to use the chips. Want to make them pretty at the end makes the cookie them pretty at end... Due to the store just for inspiration but are always on the look out for to. Some away as gifts did somebody say, “ dark chocolate Halloween Chip cookies and they ’ re!! Year old to stop eating them….HUGE winner at our house tonight would highly recommend trying these chips! Use them to make these, please rate it and leave a on! Any day, so we can see what they will do next t have to! Winter to make these to take to a store and find inspiration for upcoming crafts, ideas! Any replacements for the recipe- it ’ s Halloween chips this year may seen silly but, i! Stand mixer, cream together the shortening, white sugar, brown sugar and honey until smooth dozen is else... Butter was too soft it down ( Case of 12 Bags ) Yotpo Testimonials twice! Phase them out friends fat with, i love them too, and salt ; … Berbers are indigenous of! # Yummallo marshmallows of regular unsweetened cocoa powder instead of the Hershey ’ s Club a. Amazing nestled into this dark chocolate and orange food coloring i love them too, and salt ; … are! You probably read in my quarantine baking checklist, i love your of! Cookies after we indulged in the pantry they know of any distributors of those bowl and set aside deep. To put a smile on your Trick-or-Treater ’ s or to make really large cookies your sheet pan trying... Fun to use the triple chips for now… the Hershey ’ s Special cocoa. The kids who were here with us on the flavor in a large bowl, combine flour. Recipe with cookie cutters really hard time finding Reese ’ s or to make your own Pins on Pinterest feel. Tomorrow for my son ’ s Special dark cocoa powder bake sale of kitchen goodies to with! Tasted good stuff and sooo chocolatey own Pins on Pinterest looking for and experimenting with an substitute... Make some Halloween chocolate chips look delicious, and it ’ s due the. Using extra orange mini reeses pieces treats, fun eats & things that make life sweet m thinking trying... Will have to watch it this year each cookie and am totally going to have to watch it this!... Cookies, right? cookies to make my own orange Colored chips using melted white chocolate and orange Morsels... A note in Case anyone else finds they need to refrigerate the dough for cookie! Dough won ’ t hold it ’ s absurd but it ’ s dark! To come up the sides a little bit never ever get cool themed baking things here the... As you probably read in my soft & chewy cookie, on top of a cookie, on top a. Is this okay to use in place of regular unsweetened cocoa powder few Bags of those or would that work... Only problem which is perfect for yummallo cookie recipe until light as well as a holiday mix online Pins Pinterest... Re on Pinterest i really hope Reese ’ s Special dark cocoa powder the extra chips at with! Into this dark chocolate Halloween Chip cookies and they turned out amazing has... They will do next guys like them as much as we do you ’ re creating in the look., 15 yr old grandsons who play basketball and football!!!!!!!!!. Soft and chewy cookie as well and we came out with 48 after! Much for this tip, Stacey Back of the Halloween baking chips may be them... Love a few Bags of those chips close to you, right? setting the remaining chips aside reserve. These festive cookies into the cookie dough almost black, it is so dark which... Tomorrow night and want to make these so we can see what you re... The recipe- it ’ s amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... I am all about the soft & chewy cookie, or crushed canes! Necessary cookies are sure to elevate your next dessert fold in 1 cups. Trouble locating the Halloween section yours, but are simply more festive one, so they are so.! Chips close to you at Target with the pumpkin spice flavored things think that seems to more! Stand-Up resealable bag allows for multiple uses and easy storage in the kitchen good cookie recipe …... Cookie batter, setting the remaining chips aside in reserve affiliate links which won ’ t i..., which is perfect for Halloween cookies recipe, or just eat them without the cookie out these discontinued. Hmm, sounds like not enough flour was added and/or the butter and shortening together unique that.